task_detail
validation/gpt-5-4/flux-pr-1839/task_detail.v1.json
18440 bytes
{
"version": "v1",
"materialization": {
"mode": "canonical"
},
"identity": {
"variant_id": "gpt-5.4",
"requested_model": "gpt-5.4",
"model_key": "gpt-5-4",
"run_id": "2026-02-28__18-27-22__gpt-5-4",
"task_id": "flux-pr-1839",
"trial_name": "flux-pr-1839.1-of-1.2026-02-28__18-27-22__gpt-5-4"
},
"decision": {
"status": "pass",
"primary_signal": "tests",
"matrix_status": "pass_with_warn",
"reason_codes": [
"primary_tests",
"tests_passed",
"equivalence_non_equivalent",
"review_fail"
],
"flags": [
"equiv_warn",
"review_warn"
],
"lane_report": {
"lane": "lane_unknown",
"source": "lane_unknown",
"reasons": [
"lane_unknown"
]
},
"publish": {
"include_in_leaderboard": true,
"weak_signal_risk": false
},
"rescue": {
"candidate": false,
"eligible": false,
"decision": "not_candidate",
"required_artifacts_ok": true
}
},
"tests": {
"outcome": "pass",
"strength": "strong",
"commands": [
"env PATH=/root/.cargo/bin:/usr/local/sbin:/usr/local/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/sbin:/bin cargo test --all-features"
],
"command_results": [
{
"command": "env PATH=/root/.cargo/bin:/usr/local/sbin:/usr/local/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/sbin:/bin cargo test --all-features",
"gold_outcome": "pass",
"gold_tb_trial_name": "flux-pr-1839.1-of-1.validate-gold-1772831961362227000",
"gold_failure_mode": "unset",
"agent_outcome": "pass",
"agent_tb_trial_name": "flux-pr-1839.1-of-1.validate-override-1772832146057541000",
"agent_failure_mode": "unset",
"agent_retried": false
}
],
"partial_score": {
"score": 1,
"numerator": 1,
"denominator": 1,
"level": "command",
"provenance": "fallback_command_level",
"reason": "test_case_detail_unavailable"
},
"tb": {
"trial_name": "flux-pr-1839.1-of-1.2026-02-28__18-27-22__gpt-5-4",
"is_resolved": false,
"failure_mode": "unset",
"duration_sec": 349.434660875,
"time_budget_sec": 1200
},
"cache": {
"cache_hit": false,
"cache_miss_reason": "missing_pinned_dependencies",
"environment_group_id": "eg_2d84f25b38a313fb6c13d2663529d655"
}
},
"quality": {
"equivalence": {
"status": "used",
"outcome": "non_equivalent",
"evaluator_model": "gpt-5.3-codex",
"confidence": 0.96,
"issue_type": "behavioral",
"notes": "The patch covers most MSSQL function additions (inline TVF `RETURN SELECT`, optional `AS`, multi-statement TVF with `RETURNS @name TABLE(...)`, and column constraints), but it changes `CreateFunction` shape globally (`return_table_name`) and does not implement the anonymous-vs-defined table return type model from intent (`RETURNS TABLE` vs `RETURNS TABLE(...)`) in the AST/type system. It also models inline return as `AsReturnQuery(Box<Query>)`, which is broader/different than intended bare-`SELECT` support and may accept forms outside the requested MSSQL semantics. Most importantly, it appears to reject `RETURN` with no expression/query in `BEGIN...END` bodies for MSSQL functions (expects `RETURN <query>` in non-BEGIN branch and no explicit handling for empty RETURN in inline branch), risking incompatibility with required multi-statement TVF behavior."
},
"code_review": {
"status": "used",
"signal": "fail",
"evaluator_model": "gpt-5.3-codex",
"confidence": 0.88,
"issue_type": "unclear",
"source_field": "code_review",
"dimension_scores": {
"correctness": {
"score_0_4": 1,
"confidence_0_1": 0.9,
"rationale": "The patch partially adds MSSQL TVF support, but key behavior diverges from the requested semantics: return-table naming is modeled separately from return type, and inline RETURN parsing is generalized as any Query rather than the requested SELECT/subquery forms. It also relies on empty-column TABLE representation rather than an explicit TABLE-without-columns type."
},
"edge_case_handling": {
"score_0_4": 1,
"confidence_0_1": 0.84,
"rationale": "Edge constraints are incomplete: RETURN body parsing accepts general Query grammar, and there is no enforcement that named table-variable RETURNS syntax is coupled specifically to a table return type representation."
},
"introduced_bug_risk": {
"score_0_4": 1,
"confidence_0_1": 0.86,
"rationale": "Adding a new CreateFunction field for return-table name introduces duplicated state and allows inconsistent combinations between return_table_name and return_type across parser/formatter paths."
},
"maintainability_idioms": {
"score_0_4": 2,
"confidence_0_1": 0.8,
"rationale": "The approach works in parts, but spreads MSSQL return semantics across additional struct fields and a broad new body variant, instead of encoding the return-type variants directly in DataType/function-body structure."
}
},
"findings": [
{
"id": "f1",
"dimension": "correctness",
"severity": "major",
"title": "Return-table variable modeled separately from return type",
"detail": "The patch introduces `return_table_name` on `CreateFunction` and parses it independently of `return_type`, allowing invalid or inconsistent states (e.g., named return variable with non-table type) rather than modeling it as a typed table return variant.",
"confidence_0_1": 0.91,
"citations": [
{
"path": "src/ast/ddl.rs",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 2258,
"end_line": 2263,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "0add6e250c468d97519f1ab46a92711e084beb19"
},
{
"path": "src/parser/mod.rs",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 5207,
"end_line": 5216,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "0add6e250c468d97519f1ab46a92711e084beb19"
}
]
},
{
"id": "f2",
"dimension": "correctness",
"severity": "major",
"title": "Inline RETURN parsing is broader than requested MSSQL semantics",
"detail": "Inline TVF RETURN body is parsed via `parse_query()` (optionally parenthesized), which accepts broader query constructs than the requested SELECT/subquery forms and may accept unsupported function bodies.",
"confidence_0_1": 0.86,
"citations": [
{
"path": "src/parser/mod.rs",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 5254,
"end_line": 5262,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "0add6e250c468d97519f1ab46a92711e084beb19"
},
{
"path": "src/ast/mod.rs",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 8769,
"end_line": 8780,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "0add6e250c468d97519f1ab46a92711e084beb19"
}
]
},
{
"id": "f3",
"dimension": "edge_case_handling",
"severity": "major",
"title": "Anonymous RETURNS TABLE is represented as empty-column table sentinel",
"detail": "New MSSQL test asserts `DataType::Table(columns)` with `columns.is_empty()` for `RETURNS TABLE`, indicating sentinel encoding instead of an explicit anonymous-table variant; this is brittle for formatting/round-tripping and does not cleanly distinguish `TABLE` vs `TABLE(...)`.",
"confidence_0_1": 0.83,
"citations": [
{
"path": "tests/sqlparser_mssql.rs",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 304,
"end_line": 317,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "0add6e250c468d97519f1ab46a92711e084beb19"
},
{
"path": "src/ast/ddl.rs",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 2332,
"end_line": 2338,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "0add6e250c468d97519f1ab46a92711e084beb19"
}
]
},
{
"id": "f4",
"dimension": "maintainability_idioms",
"severity": "minor",
"title": "Cross-dialect churn from adding required field on shared AST struct",
"detail": "Adding `return_table_name` required touching many dialect tests/constructors that are unrelated to MSSQL behavior, increasing maintenance burden versus containing MSSQL semantics within type variants.",
"confidence_0_1": 0.79,
"citations": [
{
"path": "tests/sqlparser_bigquery.rs",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 2144,
"end_line": 2147,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "0add6e250c468d97519f1ab46a92711e084beb19"
},
{
"path": "tests/sqlparser_postgres.rs",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 4135,
"end_line": 4140,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "0add6e250c468d97519f1ab46a92711e084beb19"
}
]
}
],
"overall": {
"overall_score_0_100": 30.000000000000004,
"signal": "fail",
"confidence_overall": 0.88,
"summary": "The patch appears to implement part of MSSQL CREATE FUNCTION TVF support, but it likely does not fully satisfy the intended change due to modeling and parsing mismatches that can produce invalid states and brittle TABLE semantics."
},
"notes": "review JSON parse recovered after one retry"
},
"behavioral_robustness": {
"status": "used",
"probe_status": "used",
"gold_pass_candidate_pass_count": 1,
"agreement_rate": 1,
"coverage_delta_status": "unavailable",
"coverage_delta_reason": "coverage_adapter_unavailable",
"mutation_lite_status": "unavailable",
"mutation_lite_reason": "mutation_runner_unavailable",
"notes": "derived from command-level outcomes; no accepted generated probes"
},
"footprint_risk": {
"status": "used",
"reason": "none",
"version": "v1",
"level": "low",
"score": 0.29789606134928953,
"flag": false,
"severe_flag": false
},
"cost": {
"status": "tokens_only",
"token_status": "present",
"cache_token_status": "present",
"total_input_tokens": 2191928,
"total_output_tokens": 10193,
"total_tokens": 2202121,
"uncached_input_tokens": 67896,
"cache_read_input_tokens": 2124032,
"cached_input_tokens": 2124032,
"total_cost_usd": 1.279352,
"token_source": "openai_cached_tokens_usage",
"pricing_model_key": "gpt-5.4",
"pricing_mode": "cache_aware"
}
},
"summary": {
"task": {
"matrix_status": "pass_with_warn",
"tests_outcome": "pass",
"tests_unknown_cause": null,
"lane_report_lane": "lane_unknown",
"lane_report_source": "lane_unknown",
"lane_report_reasons": [
"lane_unknown"
],
"cache_hit": false,
"cache_miss_reason": "missing_pinned_dependencies",
"setup_ms_saved": null,
"pinned_bytes": null,
"environment_group_id": "eg_2d84f25b38a313fb6c13d2663529d655",
"equivalence_status": "used",
"equivalence_outcome": "non_equivalent",
"code_review_status": "used",
"code_review_signal": "fail",
"behavioral_robustness_status": "used",
"coverage_delta_status": "unavailable",
"mutation_lite_status": "unavailable",
"probe_accepted_candidates": null,
"probe_accepted_commands": null,
"probe_agreement_rate": 1,
"probe_gold_pass_candidate_pass_count": 1,
"probe_gold_pass_candidate_fail_count": null,
"probe_review_required_count": null,
"flags": [
"equiv_warn",
"review_warn"
],
"tb_is_resolved": false,
"tb_failure_mode": "unset",
"tb_total_input_tokens": 2191928,
"tb_total_output_tokens": 10193,
"tb_total_tokens": 2202121,
"tb_uncached_input_tokens": 67896,
"tb_cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
"tb_cache_read_input_tokens": 2124032,
"tb_cached_input_tokens": 2124032,
"token_status": "present",
"cache_token_status": "present",
"token_source": "openai_cached_tokens_usage",
"task_cost": 1.279352,
"cost_status": "present",
"cost_pricing_mode": "cache_aware",
"pricing_model_key": "gpt-5.4",
"equiv_rescue_policy": "on",
"rescue_candidate": false,
"rescue_eligible": false,
"rescue_decision": "not_candidate",
"publish_include_in_leaderboard": true,
"publish_exclusion_reasons": [],
"publish_weak_signal_risk": false,
"tests_only_outcome": 1,
"rescue_aware_outcome": 1,
"partial_score": 1,
"partial_score_numerator": 1,
"partial_score_denominator": 1,
"partial_score_level": "command",
"partial_score_provenance": "fallback_command_level",
"partial_score_reason": "test_case_detail_unavailable",
"partial_score_unknown_count": 0,
"footprint_risk_status": "used",
"footprint_risk_reason": "none",
"footprint_risk_level": "low",
"footprint_risk_score": 0.29789606134928953,
"footprint_risk_flag": false,
"footprint_risk_severe_flag": false
},
"run": {
"model": "gpt-5.4",
"requested_model": "gpt-5.4",
"run_id": "2026-02-28__18-27-22__gpt-5-4",
"passRate": 1,
"ciLow": 1,
"ciHigh": 1,
"effectiveN": 30,
"tier": 1,
"validation_counts": {
"fail_guardrail": 0,
"fail_high_conf": 0,
"fail_infra": 0,
"fail_likely_equiv": 0,
"fail_with_diag": 0,
"missing": 0,
"pass": 5,
"pass_with_warn": 25
}
},
"run_metadata": {
"agent_name": "codex",
"model_name": "gpt-5.4",
"start_time": "2026-03-06T15:25:43.932417+00:00",
"end_time": "2026-03-06T17:16:29.393831+00:00",
"commit_hash": "8f1bc9fe2c3cb8a14c254de41e9577a2ce352ac2",
"accuracy": 0.2,
"reasoning_effort": "medium"
}
},
"evidence": {
"task_detail": {
"path": "validation/gpt-5-4/flux-pr-1839/task_detail.v1.json",
"exists": true
},
"trajectory": {
"path": "validation/gpt-5-4/flux-pr-1839/trajectory.v1.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 15261
},
"validation": {
"path": "validation/gpt-5-4/flux-pr-1839/validation.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 130869
},
"results": {
"path": "runs/2026-02-28__18-27-22__gpt-5-4/results.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 60973
},
"run_metadata": {
"path": "runs/2026-02-28__18-27-22__gpt-5-4/run_metadata.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 1635
},
"agent_patch": {
"path": "runs/2026-02-28__18-27-22__gpt-5-4/flux-pr-1839/flux-pr-1839.1-of-1.2026-02-28__18-27-22__gpt-5-4/agent-logs/agent.patch",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 13926
},
"summary": {
"path": "reports/summary.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 280264
},
"manifest": {
"path": "manifest.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 675
},
"validation_inputs": {
"required_for_rescue_ok": true,
"gold_patch": {
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 8391,
"sha256": "64f5330be7f38160230e4fac4e74e3962ffa93858810ae3629bb4258e3bbb969",
"required_for_rescue": true
},
"repo_tarball": {
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 744432,
"sha256": "edd0e8d362329fc3dad5e73b7ba0d2838422f4690d7f6f02f950bee15b6ec7c4",
"required_for_rescue": true
},
"agent_patch": {
"path": "runs/2026-02-28__18-27-22__gpt-5-4/flux-pr-1839/flux-pr-1839.1-of-1.2026-02-28__18-27-22__gpt-5-4/agent-logs/agent.patch",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 13926,
"sha256": "8482aa38af3cfe4e79046355dc4157fe23abd2369e53112d03db5fab6c47fb1d",
"required_for_rescue": true
}
}
},
"provenance": {
"identity": [
{
"source": "manifest",
"available": true
},
{
"source": "tb_results",
"available": true
}
],
"decision": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
}
],
"tests": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
},
{
"source": "tb_results",
"available": true
}
],
"quality": {
"equivalence": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
}
],
"code_review": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
}
],
"behavioral_robustness": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
}
],
"footprint_risk": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
}
],
"cost": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
},
{
"source": "summary",
"available": true
}
]
},
"summary": {
"task": [
{
"source": "summary",
"available": true
}
],
"run": [
{
"source": "summary",
"available": true
}
],
"run_metadata": [
{
"source": "run_metadata",
"available": true
}
]
},
"evidence": [
{
"source": "filesystem",
"available": true
}
]
}
}