task_detail
validation/gpt-5-3-codex/flux-pr-1169/task_detail.v1.json
17244 bytes
{
"version": "v1",
"materialization": {
"mode": "canonical"
},
"identity": {
"variant_id": "gpt-5.3-codex",
"requested_model": "gpt-5.3-codex",
"model_key": "gpt-5-3-codex",
"run_id": "2026-02-28__13-38-10__gpt-5-3-codex",
"task_id": "flux-pr-1169",
"trial_name": "flux-pr-1169.1-of-1.2026-02-28__13-38-10__gpt-5-3-codex"
},
"decision": {
"status": "pass",
"primary_signal": "tests",
"matrix_status": "pass_with_warn",
"reason_codes": [
"primary_tests",
"tests_passed",
"equivalence_non_equivalent",
"review_fail"
],
"flags": [
"equiv_warn",
"review_warn"
],
"publish": {
"include_in_leaderboard": true,
"weak_signal_risk": false
},
"rescue": {
"candidate": false,
"eligible": false,
"decision": "not_candidate",
"required_artifacts_ok": true
}
},
"tests": {
"outcome": "pass",
"strength": "strong",
"commands": [
"go test -C v2 ./... -count=1 -timeout=300s"
],
"command_results": [
{
"command": "go test -C v2 ./... -count=1 -timeout=300s",
"gold_outcome": "pass",
"gold_tb_trial_name": "flux-pr-1169.1-of-1.validate-gold-1772290105636749000",
"gold_failure_mode": "unset",
"agent_outcome": "pass",
"agent_tb_trial_name": "flux-pr-1169.1-of-1.validate-override-1772290163265409000",
"agent_failure_mode": "unset",
"agent_retried": false
}
],
"partial_score": {
"score": 1,
"numerator": 1,
"denominator": 1,
"level": "command",
"provenance": "fallback_command_level",
"reason": "test_case_detail_unavailable"
},
"tb": {
"trial_name": "flux-pr-1169.1-of-1.2026-02-28__13-38-10__gpt-5-3-codex",
"is_resolved": false,
"failure_mode": "unset",
"duration_sec": 107.367651708,
"time_budget_sec": 1200
},
"cache": {
"cache_hit": false,
"cache_miss_reason": "missing_pinned_dependencies",
"environment_group_id": "eg_46b6a6c82a4890b6e6e87c39575fd02c"
}
},
"quality": {
"equivalence": {
"status": "used",
"outcome": "non_equivalent",
"confidence": 0.89,
"issue_type": "behavioral",
"notes": "The patch captures part of the intent (spec-like field-selection messages and adding locations), but it misses core behavior: it drops `DefaultOperationValidator` option processing entirely (so Apollo compatibility flags no longer work), applies validation metadata unconditionally instead of via the new centralized compatibility mechanism/flag, and differs in error-location semantics (uses field position rather than selection-set brace for leaf-selection errors). It also omits at least one message alignment present in the intended change (e.g., inline fragment mismatch text)."
},
"code_review": {
"status": "used",
"signal": "fail",
"confidence": 0.87,
"issue_type": "unclear",
"source_field": "code_review",
"dimension_scores": {
"correctness": {
"score_0_4": 1,
"confidence_0_1": 0.9,
"rationale": "The patch drops option application in the validator constructor, changing runtime behavior for existing Option-based compatibility controls, and it keeps scalar-enclosing-type handling that emits a leaf-selection error shape instead of undefined-field semantics for nested selections on scalar parents."
},
"edge_case_handling": {
"score_0_4": 1,
"confidence_0_1": 0.81,
"rationale": "The scalar parent case is explicitly handled with ErrFieldSelectionOnScalar, which is a poor fit for queries selecting fields from scalar types; this edge behavior is central to GraphQL field-selection validation correctness."
},
"introduced_bug_risk": {
"score_0_4": 1,
"confidence_0_1": 0.84,
"rationale": "Behavior is now globally mutated at validation time for all external errors, and prior option-sensitive paths were removed, increasing the chance of regressions in callers relying on previous compatibility flag semantics."
},
"maintainability_idioms": {
"score_0_4": 2,
"confidence_0_1": 0.78,
"rationale": "The patch changes public error-constructor signatures and shifts semantics by side effects in Validate, while simultaneously removing tests that exercised old compatibility-flag behavior, making intent harder to reason about and regressions harder to detect."
}
},
"findings": [
{
"id": "f1",
"dimension": "correctness",
"severity": "major",
"title": "DefaultOperationValidator no longer applies provided options",
"detail": "The constructor removed the options accumulation loop, so Option inputs are ignored. This breaks compatibility-flag driven behavior and changes API semantics beyond the stated scope.",
"confidence_0_1": 0.95,
"citations": [
{
"path": "v2/pkg/astvalidation/operation_validation.go",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 25,
"end_line": 30,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "57b5188"
}
]
},
{
"id": "f2",
"dimension": "correctness",
"severity": "major",
"title": "Scalar-parent field selection path emits wrong error category",
"detail": "EnterField still routes scalar enclosing types to ValidateScalarField, which returns a leaf-selection error. For selecting a field on a scalar parent type, GraphQL semantics expect an undefined-field style error on that type.",
"confidence_0_1": 0.86,
"citations": [
{
"path": "v2/pkg/astvalidation/operation_rule_validate_field_selections.go",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 69,
"end_line": 89,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "57b5188"
},
{
"path": "v2/pkg/operationreport/externalerror.go",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 161,
"end_line": 165,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "57b5188"
}
]
},
{
"id": "f3",
"dimension": "introduced_bug_risk",
"severity": "major",
"title": "Validation metadata is forced for all errors without compatibility gating",
"detail": "applyValidationErrorMetadata is always invoked when any validation error exists, so ExtensionCode and StatusCode are overwritten by default. This removes prior opt-in behavior and can alter consumers expecting legacy error envelopes.",
"confidence_0_1": 0.83,
"citations": [
{
"path": "v2/pkg/astvalidation/operation_validation.go",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 83,
"end_line": 96,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "57b5188"
}
]
},
{
"id": "f4",
"dimension": "maintainability_idioms",
"severity": "major",
"title": "Test updates remove compatibility-flag behavioral coverage",
"detail": "The prior test matrix validating both true/false Apollo compatibility propagation was replaced by a single always-on expectation, reducing regression protection for option-driven behavior.",
"confidence_0_1": 0.79,
"citations": [
{
"path": "v2/pkg/astvalidation/operation_validation_test.go",
"side": "new",
"start_line": 4673,
"end_line": 4710,
"anchor_kind": "diff",
"head_sha": "57b5188"
}
]
}
],
"overall": {
"confidence_overall": 0.87,
"summary": "The agent patch only partially matches the intended PR and introduces behavioral regressions: options are no longer applied in validator construction, scalar field-selection validation remains semantically off, and validation metadata is applied unconditionally rather than via centralized compatibility control."
},
"notes": "The agent patch only partially matches the intended PR and introduces behavioral regressions: options are no longer applied in validator construction, scalar field-selection validation remains semantically off, and validation metadata is applied unconditionally rather than via centralized compatibility control."
},
"behavioral_robustness": {
"status": "used",
"probe_status": "used",
"gold_pass_candidate_pass_count": 1,
"agreement_rate": 1,
"coverage_delta_status": "unavailable",
"coverage_delta_reason": "coverage_adapter_unavailable",
"mutation_lite_status": "unavailable",
"mutation_lite_reason": "mutation_runner_unavailable",
"notes": "derived from command-level outcomes; no accepted generated probes"
},
"footprint_risk": {
"status": "used",
"reason": "none",
"version": "v1",
"level": "low",
"score": 0.29953545357263966,
"flag": false,
"severe_flag": false
},
"cost": {
"status": "tokens_only",
"token_status": "present",
"cache_token_status": "present",
"total_input_tokens": 2907171,
"total_output_tokens": 11460,
"total_tokens": 2918631,
"uncached_input_tokens": 80803,
"cache_read_input_tokens": 2826368,
"cached_input_tokens": 2826368,
"total_cost_usd": 6.139196999999999,
"token_source": "openai_cached_tokens_usage",
"pricing_model_key": "gpt-5.3-codex",
"pricing_mode": "cache_aware"
}
},
"summary": {
"task": {
"matrix_status": "pass_with_warn",
"tests_outcome": "pass",
"tests_unknown_cause": null,
"lane_report_lane": null,
"lane_report_source": null,
"lane_report_reasons": null,
"cache_hit": false,
"cache_miss_reason": "missing_pinned_dependencies",
"setup_ms_saved": null,
"pinned_bytes": null,
"environment_group_id": "eg_46b6a6c82a4890b6e6e87c39575fd02c",
"equivalence_status": "used",
"equivalence_outcome": "non_equivalent",
"code_review_status": "used",
"code_review_signal": "fail",
"behavioral_robustness_status": "used",
"coverage_delta_status": "unavailable",
"mutation_lite_status": "unavailable",
"probe_accepted_candidates": null,
"probe_accepted_commands": null,
"probe_agreement_rate": 1,
"probe_gold_pass_candidate_pass_count": 1,
"probe_gold_pass_candidate_fail_count": null,
"probe_review_required_count": null,
"flags": [
"equiv_warn",
"review_warn"
],
"tb_is_resolved": false,
"tb_failure_mode": "unset",
"tb_total_input_tokens": 2907171,
"tb_total_output_tokens": 11460,
"tb_total_tokens": 2918631,
"tb_uncached_input_tokens": 80803,
"tb_cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
"tb_cache_read_input_tokens": 2826368,
"tb_cached_input_tokens": 2826368,
"token_status": "present",
"cache_token_status": "present",
"token_source": "openai_cached_tokens_usage",
"task_cost": 6.139196999999999,
"cost_status": "present",
"cost_pricing_mode": "cache_aware",
"pricing_model_key": "gpt-5.3-codex",
"equiv_rescue_policy": "on",
"rescue_candidate": false,
"rescue_eligible": false,
"rescue_decision": "not_candidate",
"publish_include_in_leaderboard": true,
"publish_exclusion_reasons": [],
"publish_weak_signal_risk": false,
"tests_only_outcome": 1,
"rescue_aware_outcome": 1,
"partial_score": 1,
"partial_score_numerator": 1,
"partial_score_denominator": 1,
"partial_score_level": "command",
"partial_score_provenance": "fallback_command_level",
"partial_score_reason": "test_case_detail_unavailable",
"partial_score_unknown_count": 0,
"footprint_risk_status": "used",
"footprint_risk_reason": "none",
"footprint_risk_level": "low",
"footprint_risk_score": 0.29953545357263966,
"footprint_risk_flag": false,
"footprint_risk_severe_flag": false
},
"run": {
"model": "gpt-5.3-codex",
"requested_model": "gpt-5.3-codex",
"run_id": "2026-02-28__13-38-10__gpt-5-3-codex",
"passRate": 0.9310344827586207,
"ciLow": 0.8275862068965517,
"ciHigh": 1,
"effectiveN": 29,
"tier": 1,
"validation_counts": {
"fail_guardrail": 0,
"fail_high_conf": 1,
"fail_infra": 0,
"fail_likely_equiv": 1,
"fail_with_diag": 0,
"missing": 0,
"pass": 6,
"pass_with_warn": 21
}
},
"run_metadata": {
"agent_name": "codex",
"model_name": "gpt-5.3-codex",
"start_time": "2026-02-28T13:38:12.733292+00:00",
"end_time": "2026-02-28T14:43:03.470912+00:00",
"commit_hash": "99ae882e59281de74856a3e7eeb1b7c986b466af",
"accuracy": 0.896551724137931,
"reasoning_effort": "medium"
}
},
"evidence": {
"task_detail": {
"path": "validation/gpt-5-3-codex/flux-pr-1169/task_detail.v1.json",
"exists": true
},
"trajectory": {
"path": "validation/gpt-5-3-codex/flux-pr-1169/trajectory.v1.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 15233
},
"validation": {
"path": "validation/gpt-5-3-codex/flux-pr-1169/validation.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 180612
},
"results": {
"path": "runs/2026-02-28__13-38-10__gpt-5-3-codex/results.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 62248
},
"run_metadata": {
"path": "runs/2026-02-28__13-38-10__gpt-5-3-codex/run_metadata.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 1634
},
"agent_patch": {
"path": "runs/2026-02-28__13-38-10__gpt-5-3-codex/flux-pr-1169/flux-pr-1169.1-of-1.2026-02-28__13-38-10__gpt-5-3-codex/agent-logs/agent.patch",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 20405
},
"summary": {
"path": "reports/summary.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 269968
},
"manifest": {
"path": "manifest.json",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 677
},
"validation_inputs": {
"required_for_rescue_ok": true,
"gold_patch": {
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 10940,
"sha256": "6f12a30ad451adb641b97861c7d346e166b038d30895e2c48a758cac4d3c3437",
"required_for_rescue": true
},
"repo_tarball": {
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 4280604,
"sha256": "b0aec80c0eb61f316ed27d0fbe664447261590a37f7d8f92cadf390b4056da87",
"required_for_rescue": true
},
"agent_patch": {
"path": "runs/2026-02-28__13-38-10__gpt-5-3-codex/flux-pr-1169/flux-pr-1169.1-of-1.2026-02-28__13-38-10__gpt-5-3-codex/agent-logs/agent.patch",
"exists": true,
"non_empty": true,
"size_bytes": 20405,
"sha256": "97388151becbc381470349d4060a9318dfff8366251d4f08453f504f8b13095a",
"required_for_rescue": true
}
}
},
"provenance": {
"identity": [
{
"source": "manifest",
"available": true
},
{
"source": "tb_results",
"available": true
}
],
"decision": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
}
],
"tests": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
},
{
"source": "tb_results",
"available": true
}
],
"quality": {
"equivalence": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
}
],
"code_review": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
}
],
"behavioral_robustness": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
}
],
"footprint_risk": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
}
],
"cost": [
{
"source": "validation",
"available": true
},
{
"source": "summary",
"available": true
}
]
},
"summary": {
"task": [
{
"source": "summary",
"available": true
}
],
"run": [
{
"source": "summary",
"available": true
}
],
"run_metadata": [
{
"source": "run_metadata",
"available": true
}
]
},
"evidence": [
{
"source": "filesystem",
"available": true
}
]
}
}