STET■

flux-pr-1169

graphql-go-tools (Go) · W2 · GPT-5.3 Codex

graphql-go-tools (Go)sqlparser-rs (Rust)Zod (TypeScript)
W2W1
|
GPT-5.1 Codex MiniGPT-5.3 CodexGPT-5.4
pass_with_warn

Tests passed. 1/1 commands passed. Strength: strong.

93.1% run pass rate
Tier 1
primary testspassednon equivalentfail
go test -C v2 ./... -count=1 -timeout=300s
gold passagent pass

Partial score: 1/1

Publishable: yesCache: miss

Trajectory

codex · partial order only

provider-native trajectory captured; validation and decision steps are appended with coarse ordering only

session start
Session started
#1
results
assistant turn
Assistant turn
#2
task detail
tool call
Command started
#3

shell command

results
tool call
Command started
#4

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#5

shell command exit code 0

results
tool result
Command finished
#6

shell command exit code 0

results
assistant turn
Assistant turn
#7
task detail
tool call
Command started
#8

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#9

shell command exit code 0

results
tool call
Command started
#10

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#11

shell command exit code 0

results
assistant turn
Assistant turn
#12
task detail
tool call
Command started
#13

shell command

results
tool call
Command started
#14

shell command

results
tool call
Command started
#15

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#16

shell command exit code 0

results
tool result
Command finished
#17

shell command exit code 0

results
tool result
Command finished
#18

shell command exit code 0

results
tool call
Command started
#19

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#20

shell command exit code 0

results
tool call
Command started
#21

shell command

results
tool call
Command started
#22

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#23

shell command exit code 0

results
tool result
Command finished
#24

shell command exit code 0

results
tool call
Command started
#25

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#26

shell command exit code 0

results
tool call
Command started
#27

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#28

shell command exit code 0

results
assistant turn
Assistant turn
#29
task detail
tool call
Command started
#30

shell command

results
tool call
Command started
#31

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#32

shell command exit code 0

results
tool result
Command finished
#33

shell command exit code 0

results
tool call
Command started
#34

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#35

shell command exit code 0

results
tool call
Command started
#36

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#37

shell command exit code 0

results
tool call
Command started
#38

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#39

shell command exit code 0

results
tool call
Command started
#40

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#41

shell command exit code 0

results
assistant turn
Assistant turn
#42
task detail
tool call
Command started
#43

shell command

results
tool call
Command started
#44

shell command

results
tool call
Command started
#45

shell command

results
tool result
Command finished
#46

shell command exit code 0

results
tool result
Command finished
#47

shell command exit code 0

results
tool result
Command finished
#48

shell command exit code 0

results
patch written
Patch captured
#49

Flux captured agent.patch for this trial

agent.patch
validation
Tests passed
#50

go

validation
equivalence
Equivalence judgment
#51

non_equivalent

validation
code review
Code review judgment
#52

fail

task detail
decision
Final decision
#53

pass_with_warn

task detail

Quality

equivalence
non_equivalent
89% confidence
code review
fail
4 findings
footprint
low (0.30)
behavioral
100.0%
cost
$6.14 · 2.9M

Equivalence Reasoning

behavioral

The patch captures part of the intent (spec-like field-selection messages and adding locations), but it misses core behavior: it drops `DefaultOperationValidator` option processing entirely (so Apollo compatibility flags no longer work), applies validation metadata unconditionally instead of via the new centralized compatibility mechanism/flag, and differs in error-location semantics (uses field position rather than selection-set brace for leaf-selection errors). It also omits at least one message alignment present in the intended change (e.g., inline fragment mismatch text).

Code Review

correctness: 1/4edge case handling: 1/4introduced bug risk: 1/4maintainability idioms: 2/4

The agent patch only partially matches the intended PR and introduces behavioral regressions: options are no longer applied in validator construction, scalar field-selection validation remains semantically off, and validation metadata is applied unconditionally rather than via centralized compatibility control.

4 findings
DefaultOperationValidator no longer applies provided options
major

The constructor removed the options accumulation loop, so Option inputs are ignored. This breaks compatibility-flag driven behavior and changes API semantics beyond the stated scope.

v2/pkg/astvalidation/operation_validation.go:25
Scalar-parent field selection path emits wrong error category
major

EnterField still routes scalar enclosing types to ValidateScalarField, which returns a leaf-selection error. For selecting a field on a scalar parent type, GraphQL semantics expect an undefined-field style error on that type.

v2/pkg/astvalidation/operation_rule_validate_field_selections.go:69
Validation metadata is forced for all errors without compatibility gating
major

applyValidationErrorMetadata is always invoked when any validation error exists, so ExtensionCode and StatusCode are overwritten by default. This removes prior opt-in behavior and can alter consumers expecting legacy error envelopes.

v2/pkg/astvalidation/operation_validation.go:83
Test updates remove compatibility-flag behavioral coverage
major

The prior test matrix validating both true/false Apollo compatibility propagation was replaced by a single always-on expectation, reducing regression protection for option-driven behavior.

v2/pkg/astvalidation/operation_validation_test.go:4673
Evidencetask_detail (—)trajectory (14.9 KB)validation (176.4 KB)results (60.8 KB)run_metadata (1.6 KB)agent_patch (19.9 KB)summary (263.6 KB)manifest (677 B)