flux-pr-1034

graphql-go-tools (Go) · W2 · GPT-5.1 Codex Mini

graphql-go-tools (Go)sqlparser-rs (Rust)Zod (TypeScript)

W2 W1

GPT-5.1 Codex Mini GPT-5.3 Codex GPT-5.4

pass_with_warn

Tests passed. 1/1 commands passed. Strength: strong.

96.6% run pass rate

Tier 1

primary testspassednon equivalentfail

go test -C v2 ./... -count=1 -timeout=300s

gold passagent pass

Partial score: 1/1

Publishable: yesCache: miss

Trajectory

codex · partial order only

provider-native trajectory captured; validation and decision steps are appended with coarse ordering only

session start

Session started

results

tool call

Command started

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

shell command exit code 2

results

tool call

Command started

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#10

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#11

shell command exit code 2

results

tool call

Command started

#12

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#13

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#14

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#15

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#16

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#17

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#18

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#19

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#20

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#21

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#22

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#23

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#24

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#25

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#26

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#27

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#28

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#29

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#30

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#31

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#32

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#33

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#34

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#35

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#36

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#37

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#38

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#39

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#40

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#41

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#42

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#43

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#44

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#45

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#46

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#47

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#48

shell command

results

patch written

Patch captured

#49

Flux captured agent.patch for this trial

agent.patch

validation

Tests passed

#50

validation

equivalence

Equivalence judgment

#51

non_equivalent

validation

code review

Code review judgment

#52

fail

task detail

decision

Final decision

#53

pass_with_warn

task detail

Quality

equivalence

non_equivalent

94% confidence

code review

fail

4 findings

footprint

medium (0.38)

behavioral

100.0%

cost

—

Equivalence Reasoning

behavioral

The patch does not implement the core v2 intent end-to-end. It mainly adds remapping in non-`v2` normalization/execution paths, while the required `v2/pkg/astnormalization` variable-mapper flow is missing. In addition, it does not clearly propagate remap usage to subgraph input rendering (the gold change maps canonical names back during context variable lookup), and the remapping logic appears declaration-order based (`v1`, `v2`, …) rather than canonicalization by variable usage shape/order in the operation.

Code Review

correctness: 1/4edge case handling: 0/4introduced bug risk: 1/4maintainability idioms: 1/4

The patch likely does not satisfy the intended v2 change: most implementation is in non-v2 paths, and the remapping strategy diverges from required structural canonicalization and end-to-end remap-aware execution/validation behavior.

4 findings

Core implementation is applied to non-v2 codepaths

major

The task expects v2 normalization/execution plumbing, but remapping logic and engine integration were added primarily under `app/pkg/...` and `app/execution/...`; the v2 tree only received partial validator message mapping changes, so the intended v2 end-to-end behavior is likely not implemented.

app/pkg/astnormalization/variables_remapping.go:1

Canonical names are assigned by variable-definition order, not usage shape

major

The visitor remaps in `EnterVariableDefinition` with per-operation counters and `v1/v2/...` naming, which does not encode first occurrence in argument traversal or mixed inline-value/variable structure. This can miss the intended normalization equivalence classes.

app/pkg/astnormalization/variables_remapping.go:31

Variable remap support in v2 validator is only cosmetic

major

In v2, the added mapping is used to rewrite displayed variable names in error strings, but there is no corresponding remap-aware variable lookup path shown for validation/execution correctness.

app/v2/pkg/variablesvalidation/variablesvalidation.go:41

Remapper mutates input JSON variables during normalization

major

The implementation deletes old keys and inserts canonical keys directly into `operation.Input.Variables`, increasing coupling between normalization and runtime input semantics and creating risk around missing keys and downstream assumptions.

app/pkg/astnormalization/variables_remapping.go:76

Evidencetask_detail (—)trajectory (15.0 KB)validation (189.2 KB)results (56.1 KB)run_metadata (1.6 KB)agent_patch (21.1 KB)summary (263.6 KB)manifest (677 B)