flux-pr-1380

graphql-go-tools (Go) · W2 · GPT-5.4

graphql-go-tools (Go)sqlparser-rs (Rust)Zod (TypeScript)

W2 W1

GPT-5.1 Codex Mini GPT-5.3 Codex GPT-5.4

pass_with_warn

Tests passed. 1/1 commands passed. Strength: strong.

89.7% run pass rate

Tier 1

primary testspassednon equivalentdecision conflictfail

go test -C v2 ./... -count=1 -timeout=300s

gold passagent pass

Partial score: 1/1

Publishable: yesCache: miss

Trajectory

codex · partial order only

provider-native trajectory captured; validation and decision steps are appended with coarse ordering only

session start

Session started

results

assistant turn

Assistant turn

task detail

tool call

Command started

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

shell command exit code 0

results

assistant turn

Assistant turn

task detail

tool call

Command started

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#10

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

#11

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#12

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

#13

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#14

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

#15

shell command exit code 0

results

assistant turn

Assistant turn

#16

task detail

tool call

Command started

#17

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

#18

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#19

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

#20

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#21

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

#22

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#23

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

#24

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#25

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

#26

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#27

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

#28

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#29

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

#30

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

#31

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#32

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

#33

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

#34

shell command exit code 0

results

assistant turn

Assistant turn

#35

task detail

tool call

Command started

#36

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

#37

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

#38

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#39

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

#40

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

#41

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#42

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

#43

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#44

shell command exit code 0

results

tool result

Command finished

#45

shell command exit code 0

results

tool call

Command started

#46

shell command

results

tool call

Command started

#47

shell command

results

tool result

Command finished

#48

shell command exit code 0

results

patch written

Patch captured

#49

Flux captured agent.patch for this trial

agent.patch

validation

Tests passed

#50

validation

equivalence

Equivalence judgment

#51

non_equivalent

validation

code review

Code review judgment

#52

fail

task detail

decision

Final decision

#53

pass_with_warn

task detail

Quality

equivalence

non_equivalent

92% confidence

code review

fail · 30/100

3 findings

footprint

low (0.13)

behavioral

100.0%

cost

$1.40 · 2.3M

Equivalence Reasoning

behavioral

Code Review

correctness: 1/4edge case handling: 1/4introduced bug risk: 1/4maintainability idioms: 2/4

The agent patch likely does not fully satisfy the intended change. It adds a narrow selection-based shortcut for @requires, but misses the broader, datasource-aware provided-field handling needed to reliably skip redundant fetches when @provides already satisfies requirements.

3 findings

Solution bypasses explicit provided-field tracking

major

The intended fix needs explicit recognition that @provides satisfies @requires along a query path. This patch only adds `areRequiresFieldsSatisfiedBySelections` and checks generic node suggestions, without implementing/using a dedicated provided-fields model, so it is likely incomplete for the target bug.

v2/pkg/engine/plan/node_selection_visitor.go:292

Datasource mismatch can cause false requires satisfaction

major

The method calls `HasSuggestionForPath` and discards the returned datasource hash, so any matching suggestion can satisfy requires even if it belongs to a different datasource, risking under-fetching.

v2/pkg/engine/plan/node_selection_visitor.go:823

Requires/provides semantics reduced to selection presence check

major

The new visitor checks whether fields exist in suggestions for computed paths, but does not encode federation-specific fallback rules for provided nested fields and accessibility the way a dedicated required-fields-provided analysis would.

v2/pkg/engine/plan/node_selection_visitor.go:785

Evidencetask_detail (—)trajectory (14.9 KB)validation (144.3 KB)results (60.3 KB)run_metadata (1.6 KB)agent_patch (9.0 KB)summary (263.6 KB)manifest (677 B)